Our Agents

Allen HeadshotAllen T. McGinniss, Agent/Principal

Allen was born and raised in Tallahassee, FL. He graduated from Leon High School and moved to Orlando to attend the University of Central Florida. He majored in Finance and minored in both Accounting and Economics. Allen received his BSBA from the Burnett Honors College at UCF graduating with Honors in May 2005.

Immediately after graduation, Allen returned to Tallahassee and began his insurance career working for a local State Farm Agency. During his 4 year State Farm Agency tenure, Allen earned his 2-15 Life & Health and General Lines 2-20 insurance licenses, as well as his Mortgage Brokers License, Series 6 Securities License. In 2008 he was accepted as a State Farm Agency Candidate.

In May of 2009 he opened the Tallahassee branch of VanAllen Insurance Agency with Michael. They grew and managed that office until January 2015 when they founded the McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency.

Allen has been married to Amanda McGinniss since 2008 (he still says it the best sale he’s ever made) and were blessed in May 2014 with twin daughters, Alyssa & Audrey, and again in February 2016 with Andrew. They also have two German Shepherds, Ava & Apollo, and their cat Annabelle.

Allen is an avid Disc Golfer and enjoys vegetable gardening and relaxing with his family and friends in his free time.

Michael HimmelMichael D. Himmel, Agent/Principal

Michael moved to Tallahassee, FL to attend Florida State University. He graduated from the College of Business with a degree in Risk Management/Insurance in 2006.

Upon graduation from Florida State, Michael went to work for a local State Farm Agency writing all lines of insurance. During his State Farm Agency tenure, Michael earned his 2-15 Life & Health and General Lines 2-20 insurance licenses, as well as his Mortgage Brokers License, Series 6 Securities License. Michael was a Financial Services Representative and Office Manager until 2009.

In May of 2009 he opened the Tallahassee branch of VanAllen Insurance Agency with Allen. They grew and managed that office until January 2015 when they founded the McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency.

Michael is a sports enthusiast and enjoys the outdoors during his free time. He has been an avid supporter of the Big Brothers Big Sisters program and has been a mentor since 2010.

Kira L. Meiners, 4-40 Licensed CSR

Kira moved to Tallahassee, FL in 1986 with her parents from Orange Park, FL.  She graduated from Leon High School, and in October 2005 started working for a local State Farm Agency. During her tenure at the State Farm Agency, Kira built a long time friendship with Allen as well as earned her 4-40 Customer Service Insurance license.

Kira’s upbeat personality, 8+ years of insurance agency experience, and ability to make everyone smile, made her the perfect fit to join Michael and Allen (again) at the VanAllen Tallahassee office in January 2011.

During Kira’s free time, she loves to cook, watch movies and spend time with her friends, family and her adorable bassett hound Jessie.  

David W. Bentley, 2-20 Licensed Agent

David, formerly a Georgia native, relocated to Florida to attend Florida Southern College in 2007. He graduated with a Bachelor of Arts degree as well as a Master in Business Administration from Florida Southern. Upon graduation, David headed north to Tallahassee to be closer to his family and to be able to actually enjoy four seasons out of the year.

During his time in college, David began his insurance journey working for GEICO and acquired his 4-40 CSR license. His 5 year stay with GEICO allowed him gained valuable knowledge of the insurance industry that helped build the foundation of his insurance career.

In 2015, David joined the McGinniss Himmel team earning his 2-15 Life & Health and General Lines 2-20 insurance licenses.

David enjoys the outdoors during his free time and looks forward to hunting season. He will always support his Georgia Bulldogs but has grown to love Florida State.

Kelly Cason, 2-20 Licensed Agent

Kelly grew up in Northern Virginia before moving to Tampa to begin working in the financial services industry. She came to Tallahassee in 1995, and while raising her kids began volunteering with the schools and local non-profit organizations.

She spent 5 years working with YoungLives, coordinating volunteers as well as working with local businesses and churches to organize donations.

Kelly began her insurance career working for a local State Farm agent as a 4-40 customer service representative. She later went on to get her 2-20 General lines and her 2-15 Life and Health license and worked as the office manager. After 3 years she left to join McGinniss Himmel team an Agent as well as director of our in house Claims Liaison program.

In her spare time, Kelly enjoys being outdoors, spending time at the gym and cooking. She has two dogs, who are considered the youngest of her children, to keep her busy. Her basic outlook on life is simply to do what you can to help others.